Sir Terry Pratchett's documentary: Choosing to Die
Dir. Charlie Russell
Broadcast on BBC2 9pm, Monday 13th June 2011
It's now nearly three months since I watched the Terry Pratchett documentary, "Choosing to Die". Not many programmes stay in the mind for long, but this one..... well.
I have spent a lot of time thinking about what we saw in the film and talking about it with friends. For me, it was a beautiful, gentle piece of work. The couple involved were incredibly dignified about the whole thing and I think they were very brave and generous to allow it all to be filmed.
We all blithely talk about terrible illnesses, pain control, hospices, but often in a detached way, yet those who are going through any of these things seldom have an opportunity to voice publicly what is happening to them. We talk in platitudes about palliative care and pain clinics, about how wonderful things are these days, often without having experienced them ourselves. It is too easy to sing the praises of medicine and assume that it is right for all.
Sir Terry Pratchett spoke at length to the people he accompanied to Switzerland. They were quite lucid and clear in their desire to end their lives, both the man with motor neuron disease and the man with MS. They had thought long and hard about their decisions and although they were possibly a little sorry that they had to die perhaps a little earlier than they might have chosen, (because of the law in the UK,) they were happy with their choice. We saw Peter Smedley's final moments as he drank the poison, became a little agitated and asked for water, and then went into a deep sleep before just not taking the next breath. It was very moving; neither gruesome nor voyeuristic.
He also spoke to a man in a hospice who was incurably ill, but who had decided to continue with palliative care and die there; Dignitas was not for him. For him, the hospice was the right choice. Terry Pratchett came down neither on one side nor the other. He is still undecided about what he wants for himself, but we were left knowing that Switzerland is a possibility for those with the wherewithal and that one can change one's mind at any point.
I was left feeling incredibly angry with people who try to deny those who are suffering, the choice of how to die. Why does anyone feel they have the right to make the choice for others about something as vital as how to die? Why do others feel that they know best what is right for someone who is suffering? If you are of sound mind yet terminally ill, surely it should be your right to end your life. We all have different pain thresholds and different outlooks on the sanctity of life.
Hopefully, this film will have persuaded some people to start talking about how we die and how we let others die. And maybe it will have shown some of those so staunchly opposed to assisted dying that there should be another way for people like Peter; people who seek a dignified and pain-free death at a time and in the manner of their choosing, at home with their loved ones.
Rhea Williams, Ipswich
















